Building an IT vendor ecosystem offers huge advantages, however,  effectively managing and evaluating vendors can be a challenge. One of the ways you can effectively manage your vendor ecosystem and the relationships with your vendors (among others) is by implementing multi-vendor scorecards. Vendor scorecards provide a standardized framework for evaluating vendor performance, service quality, compliance, and more.

In this blog post, we’ll discuss vendor scorecards in more depth: what they are, what they can and should include, and how you can use them. And at the end (here’s the link, if you’re looking for it) we’ve provided a free downloadable vendor scorecard spreadsheet for you to start using right away.

What is an IT vendor scorecard?

IT vendor scorecards are tools used by enterprise companies to evaluate and assess the performance and capabilities of their IT vendors. These scorecards provide a systematic and structured approach to measure various aspects of vendor performance, such as service quality, reliability, security, responsiveness, and overall value delivered.

The primary purpose of IT vendor scorecards is to help you make informed decisions about your vendor relationships. By assessing and comparing vendors using standardized criteria, scorecards help identify vendors that best align with your business needs and objectives.

Scorecards facilitate the evaluation process, ensuring that vendor selection and ongoing management are based on objective and measurable criteria rather than subjective opinions.

Not only can IT vendor scorecards be used in the vendor selection process, but they can (and should!) be used for the continuous improvement and management of your IT vendor ecosystem.

How to effectively use IT vendor scorecards

One of the best things about vendor scorecards is that they’re customizable to your business needs. Here are six key steps that you can follow to most effectively use IT vendor scorecards:

‍

1. Define your evaluation criteria

Identify the specific factors that are important to your organization and should be considered when assessing vendors. These criteria can include technical expertise, service-level agreements (SLAs), pricing, innovation, vendor financial stability, compliance with industry regulations, and more.

2. Assign weights and metrics

Assign weights to each evaluation criterion to reflect its relative importance to your business. This one is super dependent on the type of business you have, your offering, and your customers. For example, if security is a critical factor, it may carry a higher weight compared to other criteria. Additionally, you should define specific metrics or benchmarks to measure each criterion point objectively.

3. Gather data and start evaluating your vendors

Collect relevant data about the performance of your vendors, such as incident response times, system uptime, customer satisfaction ratings, and any other relevant performance indicators. Evaluate each vendor based on the defined metrics and calculate scores accordingly. It can sometimes be useful to gather a few team members with knowledge of the vendors being compared to score individually, then come together for the next step.

4. Analyze and compare the results

Analyze the scores and feedback received about each vendor and compare them to determine their relative strengths and weaknesses. Consider the overall performance as well as how well they meet your specific business requirements now, and how you believe they’ll be able to do so in the future.

5. Make data-informed decisions

Use the vendor scorecards as a basis for decision-making. Select vendors that have consistently performed well align with your priorities and provide the best overall value. Consider any areas of improvement identified through the evaluation process and discuss them with vendors for potential enhancements. That’s not to say that so-called ‘soft’ or qualitative factors aren’t important — your gut feeling about a vendor and your relationship should always be accounted for in some way too.

6. Ongoing vendor management

Continuously monitor and measure vendor performance using your scorecard, and remember to periodically review and update the evaluation criteria as needed. This ensures that vendors are held accountable and are meeting your expectations throughout the duration of the relationship.

By using IT vendor scorecards, you can streamline your vendor evaluation processes, make better data-driven decisions, and establish strong and productive relationships with your IT vendors.

These scorecards provide transparency, consistency, and a framework for objective assessment, ultimately contributing to improved vendor performance and better alignment with your business goals.

Example criteria for your IT vendor scorecard

Below, we’ve listed some evaluation criteria (that are also included in the downloadable spreadsheet at the end of this post) that you could use to start creating your own vendor scorecard.

Example evaluation criteria

Service quality

• Response time to support requests
• Incident resolution time
• Availability of 24/7 support
• Service-level agreement (SLA) adherence
  
  

Reliability and performance

• System uptime and availability
• Downtime Incidents and their impact
• Scalability and ability to handle peak loads
• Performance benchmarks
  
  

Security

• Data protection measures
• Compliance with relevant security standards
• Incident response and vulnerability management
• Security audits and certifications
  
  

Responsiveness and communication

• Timeliness and effectiveness of communication
• Proactive issue identification and notification
• Account management and relationship building
• Escalation procedures and resolution management
  
  

Pricing and value

• Cost structure and transparency
• Flexibility in pricing models
• Value delivered in relation to cost
• Competitive pricing compared to industry standards
  
  

Innovation and future-readiness

• Technology roadmap and vision
• Investment in research and development
• Adoption of emerging technologies
• Ability to support future business requirements
  
  

Integration capabilities

• Experience in integrating with third-party tools and systems
• Availability of APIs and integration frameworks
• Compatibility with commonly used platforms and technologies
• Successful track record of seamless integrations with customers and other vendors

‍

After you’ve decided on your own evaluation criteria, here’s what you should do next:

• Assign weights to each evaluation criterion based on their importance to your organization (these should add up to a total of 100%)
• Evaluate each vendor on a scale of 1 to 5 for each criterion, with 5 being the highest score
• Calculate the weighted score for each criterion by multiplying the vendor's score by its respective weight
• Sum up the weighted scores for each vendor to calculate their total score
• Use your completed scorecard to make better decisions 😊
  ‍

Download your IT vendor scorecard template

To give you a few minutes back in your day, we’ve created an example IT vendor scorecard with pre-filled calculations and evaluation criteria. Download it below to get started!